Tony's Pier Restaurant Logo

Fried, broiled & raw seafood, plus a menu of burgers, BBQ & wings, served in a no-frills settings.


About Tony's Pier Restaurant

Tony’s Pier Restaurant is a 276-seat, cash-only seafood restaurant offering items such as fried shrimp platters, steamers, and crab clusters. Bar has an inexpensive selection of pina coladas. Open seven days a week, Sunday to Thursday from 11:30am to 11:30pm and Friday and Saturday from 11:30am to 12:00am. Tony’s Pier classic menu of clams, oysters, lobster and fried shrimp, flounder, calamari, scallops and all things from out of the sea (along with burgers and chicken, just in case). Diners have their choice of outdoor or indoor cafeteria-style seating at this casual eatery; either option offers views of the water, just a stone’s throw away.

This is how Tony's Pier does seafood.

Open for take out

Free Delivery for City Island Residents

To Help Stop The Spread Of The Corona Virus, And Practice “Social Distancing,” Mayor De Blasio has ordered all restaurants to serve take out and delivery only. We Will Be Closely Monitoring The Recommendations Of The CDC And Local Public Officials And Look Forward To Reopening Our Doors And Once Again Offering You A Great Dining Experience In A Safe And Healthy Environment When The Time Permits. We Thank You From The Bottom Of Our Hearts For Your Patronage Over The Years And Ask For Your Patience And Understanding During This Unprecedented Time In History. We Will Keep Our Customers, Staff, And All Of Their Families In Our Prayers During This Difficult Time.

Take Out Hours:
Sunday - Thursday: 11:30 AM To 9 PM
Friday - Saturday: 11:30 AM To 10 PM